PDA

View Full Version : PS Comp 54 Voting


jamesy
Apr 16, 2007, 2:49 AM
Heres the voting thread:

Ravenous:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/1891/cobaltss3og9lm4ct5.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Jamesy:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/6314/cobaltchopba1nc6.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Robbie:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/8677/cobaltss3og9vm5.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

SKR34:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/8894/cobaltwl0.png (http://imageshack.us)

Clutch:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/7250/cobaltss3og9hi6kf4.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Car Lover:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/7745/pscomp54vo5.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Rich:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/1835/chevroletcobaltssscf3ju2.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Bennyboy:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/5065/cobaltcopyqg5pk5.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

E-TEC 4:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/6027/pontiacg5sscoupedn8jj8.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Skyline_luva19:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/2533/cobaltsspscomp54th6nl0.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Altova:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/6956/6769d1176568320cobaltssgd2.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

GT King:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/9997/pscomp54sq7mi2.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Sonicadg:
http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/8229/cobaltsscopy2uj7.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Ferrari Underground:
[/URL][URL=http://imageshack.us]http://img441.imageshack.us/img441/9980/6780d1176701629ferrariujz5.jpg (http://img441.imageshack.us/my.php?image=chevroletcobaltssscf3ju2.jp g)

Don't do that crappy point system voting thing. Just vote for who you want.

Ferrari Underground
Apr 16, 2007, 2:51 AM
one slight problem my friend... where's my entry?? lol. mine's an attachment, can you go put my entry up please thanks ;)

jamesy
Apr 16, 2007, 2:59 AM
one slight problem my friend... where's my entry?? lol. mine's an attachment, can you go put my entry up please thanks ;)
Crap sorry about that. I didn't see yours because it was an attachment. Its up there now.

Ferrari Underground
Apr 16, 2007, 3:10 AM
ok jamesy, thanks buddy for posting up my entry. ;)

Alright, here's my vote: I'm voting for Sonicadg, his one's good, I like the vynil and the badboy headlights... look awesome...

anyways, just incase, i'm voting for a second person's entry.... just incase..... anyways, for the second place entry of mine, i choose Altova.... just remember, thats my second entry, not my first one....

so basically I'm voting for Sonicadg....

slezak12
Apr 16, 2007, 3:29 AM
1st place - Rich because i love what he did to the front end plus his chop is very clean and nice overall

2nd place - Sonicdg because i really like his paint job.

good job guys.

GT King
Apr 16, 2007, 3:39 AM
Argh, this is really hard, i really like sonic's, atlova's, jamesy's, skyline_luva's and car lover's chop. Hmm...:-k

1st place: Sonicadg, his chop is just superb, i just really like the paint job, a nice blend of red, yellow and orange. I also like the flame vinyl and the bad boy headlights.

2nd Place: car lover, very good chop, i like the carbon fibre bonnet, the yellow window tint and the 911 rims. It really goes in well with the car.

shortrootand scarecrow
Apr 16, 2007, 4:22 AM
O.K, then, I will vote for Altova, and if there is a second vote I will vote for Robbie.

First place: Altova

Second place: Robbie

Robbie
Apr 16, 2007, 6:37 AM
weee, thanks for the vote...:p im jst awful at doing cardbox bodykits, darn, gotta work more on that...

First place: Sonicadg hes done great chops and darn, thats even better, looks like thats the best chop ive seen from you...

Second place: darn, its between Bennyboy and Rich, benny did a very nice chop, i love those designs, but rich has done a great job on changing the front bumper...

bah, ill go for Bennyboy this time

jamesy
Apr 16, 2007, 6:50 AM
Oh sh*t I didn't vote. I vote for Bennyboy.

car lover !!
Apr 16, 2007, 7:42 AM
Everyone did a great job. Thats all I could say.

1st place - jamesy. I know, I got bored with all those rims and Evolution 9 bumper but however, I think it's the best among most of the chops.

2nd place - bennyboy. He really did a great job. You came so close to 2nd. You messed up with those grilles. If not, you'll probably get my vote for 1st.

Consolation Prizes
rich, you chop is great but too much thing is added to the car. I know you are a great chopper. Subtle changes will do, not too much like what you've did.

skyline luva, you did a great job too but it's too messy. Those rims don't really fit the car as you chopped the top. It probably means the car should be a dragster because it really looks like one to me.

altova, the front looks too fake imo. Nice job anyway!

GT King, purges looks kinda fake. Those rims look flat and they don't match with the scene. They just don't. I wanted to apply those rims on but I didn't. =)

sonicadg, nice job. I somehow feel weird about that chop. I don't know why, weird.

astonmartin138
Apr 16, 2007, 12:00 PM
1st = bennyboy

Don't get me wrong, the others were great, but this one showed the best PS skill.

Now for the others in detail (boring for most, but anyway):

RAVENOUS:- Thats one of the best MS paint chops I've seen, perhaps bar SKR34's. Still, it shows you can keep a steadier hand than me! Make those rims 20" and you'd have yourself a pretty nice car.

JAMESY:- I like yours - the eyelids match the base colour well - which from personal experience is sometimes difficult to accomplish. What I would say is that the Evo front bumper is a little out of proportion when you look from left to right along the bottom, but the whole bodykit is blended well. I don't know whether this is true, but you use those wheels alot!

ROBBIE:- I admire, as with the other MS Paint chops, that you used what you had and came out with not a half bad result. The stripes look clean - I think the darker green is shading over the light green - am I right? Well, either way they look clean. The cardboard bumper refers to Nivleks previous chop and I'm not really a fan of itas it shows little PS skill because of the absense of the need to blend it, but its in perspective and looks fairly realistic for a MS Paint chop. Blacking out the headlamps wasn't a great idea, though.

SKR34:- An amazingly smooth MS Paint tune - the vinyl and stripes add a retro cartoon effect which has been instigated well and fits with the whole tune. The coloured wheels aren't really to my taste though, but everything else seems pretty smooth and nice - especially for an MS Paint tune.

CLUTCH:- It looks like you've intergrated some PS into the rest of it - not sure whether MS Paint or PS was used - but you've matched the wheel colour pretty spot on. Your blending needs a little work though - it looks a little odd, and the black rear window and spoiler look a little uneven. The lights, however, are pretty clever - different to those which have the full headlight covered.

CAR LOVER:- Wow - thats pretty impressive. The subtle bodykit is an improvement over the standard one, and the carbon fiber is clean except for the part just above the upper grille. The price list is inventive too, and the rims match the background pretty spot on in terms of the dominant hue. All in all, very impressive.

RICH0984:- I like the design - it differs from the rest of them - very unique. The headlamps are a little strange - I think they look better left alone. The wheels match well, but above the front wheelarch and around the rear bumper the original red shows up a little. The blue vinyl is very tasteful on the white, though, and I like the bodykit. The vent and window could've been done cleaner, though. Nice chop all in all - showing alot of PS skill.

BENNYBOY:- The grey with the racing vinyl won me over, although the vinyl has HONDA on it when its a Chevrolet. The wheels have too much of an orange hue to match the background, but they look good on the car so I can see why you chose them. Around the rear end of the sideskirt and the rear overhang red can be seen through. I like the overall chop, though.

E-TEC 4:- I do like alot of your tunes, but now you've started using photo filter the realism has been taken out of them. The wheels look a little fake, too, but I like the spoiler alot and the tint looks pretty clean.

SKYLINE_LUVA19:- Very, very nice - this would along with jamesy's, be next if there were latter positions. The chop top has been instigated well, although tell tale red can be seen around the windscreen. The fade from yellow to blue has been worked in realistically, and I like the vinyl. Its very inventive, all in all.

ALTOVA:- The lens flare isn't to my taste, and it covers alot of your work. The front bumper doesn't match that well with the rest of the car, and it looks a little scratchy ansharp around the underside. I like the rims, though.

GT KING:- The nitrous bursts are more realistic than I could manage, but I dislike the neon - I'd steer clear of it unless you are a truly talented PSer - its a nightmare to blend. The mesh looks good too, but the wheels have too many reflections to match the image and the Mercedes logos on them give it away.

SONICADG:- I see you put the trick I told you to do pearlesceant paint into action - and I must say it's been done well, but a little unrealistically. I like the bad boy bonnet and the vinyl although the side exhaust doesn't match (its hard to find one that does, though!).

FERRARI UNDERGROUND: Before I start, I need to tell you. Use higher res images. Your convertible chop might've passed if you'dve used a high res image - its blatantly blurry. The paint is a nice tone, but it looks unrealistic, however the vinyl is very nice.

Please don't take offence at any of these comments - they are constructive criticism and are there to help you improve - after all, theres always room for it. I realise I'm not the best PSer either, but I think it helps to hear a second party opinion.

Thanks, this took a while to write, but I hope to keep it up for future PS comps.

Robbie
Apr 16, 2007, 12:07 PM
ROBBIE:- I admire, as with the other MS Paint chops, that you used what you had and came out with not a half bad result. The stripes look clean - I think the darker green is shading over the light green - am I right? Well, either way they look clean. The cardboard bumper refers to Nivleks previous chop and I'm not really a fan of itas it shows little PS skill because of the absense of the need to blend it, but its in perspective and looks fairly realistic for a MS Paint chop. Blacking out the headlamps wasn't a great idea, though.


heh, thanks, to be honest, that was the best, longest, most awsome review ive heard/seen on my MS Paint chops...thanks, and yea, those stripes, i wanted to follow nivlek (sorry:p) making that darn green a sticker, then when i stuck the other colours to it, it just didnt work out, havent saved my work yet and my undo button is not working well as usual because you could only undo 3 steps :mad: ...but yea, its a pretty good chop, i reckon that if those stripes are gone, it would be cool, and does anyone know that i smoothed out the badges, rear window, door handle and the rear reflector? it just looks so clean to me that i think its just normal lol

astonmartin138
Apr 16, 2007, 12:20 PM
Yeah - it must've been clean - I didn't notice it.

Lp640
Apr 16, 2007, 12:48 PM
the oreder i think
Benny
Rich
Gt King
JAmesy
Sonic
Skyline luva
car lover
SKR34
Altova
e-tech
Ferrari underground
Robbie
Ravenous
and
Clutch

sonicadg
Apr 16, 2007, 3:19 PM
SONICADG:- I see you put the trick I told you to do pearlesceant paint into action - and I must say it's been done well, but a little unrealistically. I like the bad boy bonnet and the vinyl although the side exhaust doesn't match (its hard to find one that does, though!).
say what. You never told me to do that

astonmartin138
Apr 16, 2007, 3:24 PM
say what. You never told me to do that

Seriously - check the photoshop thread after RICH0984 posted the peugeot 207 he tuned with pearls. Was it you? I told someone...

bennyboy
Apr 18, 2007, 12:17 PM
Oh sh*t I didn't vote. I vote for Bennyboy.

bah, ill go for Bennyboy this time

Everyone did a great job. Thats all I could say.


2nd place - bennyboy. He really did a great job. You came so close to 2nd. You messed up with those grilles. If not, you'll probably get my vote for 1st.

1st = bennyboy

the oreder i think
Benny
Rich
Gt King
JAmesy
Sonic
Skyline luva
car lover
SKR34
Altova
e-tech
Ferrari underground
Robbie
Ravenous
and
Clutch

Thank you all very much guys, it's appreciated. :)

Anyway, I vote for Jamesy. It's very clean and it's well done aswell.